@AndyShore There are going to be some contestants that survive tonight that should really go. Haeley Vaughn is going to be one of them. Michelle Delamor deserves to go home, just for singing Creed. The judges killed Didi Benami, but I hope she gets another shot. Tim Urban better not make it another week. He’s had more than enough chances. I didn’t like Aaron Kelly’s performance either, but I have a feeling he doesn’t go home. Speaking of which…
8:04 The top 20 are singing “I Gotta Feeling.” That high 5 between Big Mike Lynche, Lee Dewyze and Andrew Garcia was so fake. The Thing would have knocked Lee and Andrew back a mile. The random autotune sounds terrible and Idol should be ashamed of using it.
8:10 Tim Urban will suck for another week. He’s like Robin from the last season of Top Chef. Todrick Hall, Big Mike and Casey James are safe. John Park, from Northbrook, IL, is going home. He’s going back to Northwestern. Double whammy.
8:21 Lee Dewyze, Aaron Kelly, Alex Lambert and Andrew Garcia are safe. Jermaine Sellers is going home. Even the teenage girls voting for American Idol realize you don’t do that to Marvin Gaye.
8:33 I’m not really a country music fan, but I’d still take Danny Gokey over most of the contestants this year. Don’t love the song, but his voice sounds great. He’s good people. I’d root for him all over again.
8:42 Lilly Scott, Paige Miles, Katie Stevens and Didi Benami are safe. Michelle Delamor is going home. That’s what you get for singing Creed. I’m 1 for 1 picking the girls so far. The downside of being right is having to hear Creed again.
8:53 Katelyn Epperly, Crystal Bowersox and Siobhan Magnus are all deservedly safe. It’s down to Haeley Vaughn and Lacey Brown. Can I go 2/2? You can put it on the board…YES! Goodbye Haeley Vaughn. Not even gonna watch her swan song. It’s time for Community and Jim & Pam’s baby.